diff --git a/2024/day08.py b/2024/day08.py
index cae6b74..a5b6b34 100644
--- a/2024/day08.py
+++ b/2024/day08.py
@@ -5,6 +5,7 @@
 
 import sys,time
 from helpingFunctions import *
+from collections import defaultdict
 
 setSampleMode(False)
 
@@ -15,18 +16,15 @@ path = getPath2Data(aocDay,aocYear)
 filename = getFilename2Data(aocDay)
 
 def identifyAntennes(data):
-    posAntennes={}
+    posAntennes=defaultdict(list)
     maxY = len(data)
     maxX = len(data[0])
     for posY in range(maxY):
         for posX in range(maxX):
             dataValue = data[posY][posX]
             if dataValue != '.':
-                try: 
-                    posAntennes[dataValue].append((posX,posY))                    
-                except:
-                    posAntennes[dataValue] = [(posX,posY)]
-    return maxY,maxX,posAntennes
+                posAntennes[dataValue].append((posX,posY))                    
+    return (maxX,maxY),posAntennes
 
 def isinGrid(pos,maxPos):
     return 0 <= pos[0] < maxPos[0] and 0 <= pos[1] < maxPos[1]
@@ -43,30 +41,45 @@ def calcAntiNodes(posAntA, posAntB,maxPos):
         return (CX,CY)
     return (-1,-1)
     
-def findAntiNodes(maxY,maxX,posAntennes):
-    maxPos = (maxX,maxY)
-    posAntiNodes=[]
-    posAntennesList = posAntennes.keys()
-    for antenne in posAntennesList:
-        for posAntA in posAntennes[antenne]:
-            for posAntB in posAntennes[antenne]:
-                if posAntA != posAntB: 
-                    antiNode = calcAntiNodes(posAntA,posAntB,maxPos)
+def findAntiNodesA(maxPos,posAntennes):
+    posAntiNodes=set()
+    for keys, antenne in posAntennes.items():
+        for (X1,Y1) in antenne:
+            for (X2,Y2) in antenne:
+                if (X1,Y1) != (X2,Y2): 
+                    antiNode = calcAntiNodes((X1,Y1),(X2,Y2),maxPos)
                     if antiNode != (-1,-1):
-                        posAntiNodes.append(antiNode)
+                        posAntiNodes.add(antiNode)
+    return posAntiNodes
+
+def bruteForceAntiNodes(maxPos,posAntennes):
+    posAntiNodes=set()
+    for Y in range(maxPos[1]):
+        for X in range(maxPos[0]):
+            for keys, antenne in posAntennes.items():
+                for (X1,Y1) in antenne:
+                    for (X2,Y2) in antenne:
+                        if (X1,Y1) != (X2,Y2):
+                            dX1 = X - X1
+                            dX2 = X - X2
+                            dY1 = Y - Y1
+                            dY2 = Y - Y2
+                            if (dX1*dY2 == dX2*dY1):
+                                posAntiNodes.add((X,Y))
     return posAntiNodes
 
 def taskA (data) -> int:
     gameScoreA = 0
-    maxY,maxX,posAntennes = identifyAntennes(data)
-    antiNodes = findAntiNodes(maxY,maxX,posAntennes)
-    antiNodes = list(set(antiNodes))
+    maxPos,posAntennes = identifyAntennes(data)
+    antiNodes = findAntiNodesA(maxPos,posAntennes)
     gameScoreA = len(antiNodes)
-    print (data)
     return gameScoreA
 
 def taskB (data) -> int:
     gameScoreB = 0
+    maxPos,posAntennes = identifyAntennes(data)
+    antiNodes = bruteForceAntiNodes(maxPos,posAntennes)
+    gameScoreB = len(antiNodes)
     return gameScoreB
 
 def task(task: int,data) -> int:
diff --git a/2024/day08/day08p1.py b/2024/day08/day08p1.py
index b285750..282316e 100644
--- a/2024/day08/day08p1.py
+++ b/2024/day08/day08p1.py
@@ -38,9 +38,9 @@ for r in range(R):
                             # To check if (r,c) (r1,c1) (r2,c2) are all on a line, check if (r,c)-(r1,c1) has the same slope as (r,c)-(r2,c2)
                             # dr1/dc1 == dr2/dc2
 
-                            if (d1==2*d2 or d1*2==d2) and 0<=r<R and 0<=c<C and (dr1*dc2 == dc1*dr2):
+                            if (d1==2*d2 or d1*2==d2) and (dr1*dc2 == dc1*dr2):
                                 A1.add((r,c))
-                            if 0<=r<R and 0<=c<C and (dr1*dc2 == dc1*dr2):
+                            if (dr1*dc2 == dc1*dr2):
                                 #print(f'{r4=} {c=} {r1=} {c1=} {r2=} {c2=} {k=} {dr1=} {dr2=} {dc1=} {dc2=}')
                                 A2.add((r,c))